NSL – Netzwerk Stadt und Landschaft ETH Zürich
  • Projects
      • Projects of the Chairs
        • Prof. Dr. Bryan T. Adey | Infrastructure Management
        • Prof. Dr. Tom Avermaete | History and Theory of Urban Design
        • Prof. Dr. Kay W. Axhausen | Traffic and Transport Planning
        • Prof. Dr. Francesco Corman | Transport Systems
        • Prof. Dr. Adrienne Grêt-Regamey | Planning of Landscape and Urban Systems (PLUS)
        • Prof. Dr. David Kaufmann | Spatial Development and Urban Policy
        • Prof. Hubert Klumpner | Architecture and Urban Design
        • Dr. Anastasios Kouvelas | Traffic Engineering and Control
        • Prof. Dr. Christian Schmid | Sociology
        • Prof. Milica Topalovic | Architecture and Territorial Planning
        • EiR PD Dr. Joris Van Wezemael | Spatial Transformation Laboratories (STL)
        • Prof. em Dr. h. c. Günther Vogt | Landscape Architecture
        • ETH Wohnforum – ETH CASE
        • NSL Archive
      • NSL Colloquia – The NSL Colloquia are a bi-annual presentation of exceptional work under a rotating theme determined by the inviting professor.
      • NSL Projects
        • Future Cities Lab Global
        • Urban Potential and Strategies in Metropolitan Territories
 – The Zurich Metropolitan Region as an Example (NFP65)
        • Landscape Visualization and Modeling Lab (LVML)
      • NSL Forum: Pandemie? Mitten im Klimawandel. Was bedeutet das für die räumliche Entwicklung der Schweiz? Ein Dialog.
      • Former Chairs
    Close
  • Teaching
    • Teaching
      • Bachelor and Master Degree Programmes, Department ARCH
      • Bachelor and Master Degree Programmes, Department BAUG
      • MSc in Spatial Development and Infrastructure Systems
      • MAS/CAS Spatial Development
      • MAS Urban and Territorial Design
      • MAS in Housing
      • Doctoral Programme in Landscape and Urban Studies
      • The teaching component of the NSL seeks to impart the knowledge and skills needed to develop the standard strengths of spatial planning and their interaction as well as the ability to develop strategies for the solution of spatial problems. These are central prerequisites for a responsible and successful exercise of planning functions in the service of the public commonwealth and of private companies. Especially important in fufilling these prerequisites is the quality of university-level education: graduate and post-graduate work as well as professional development in spatial, urban and landscape planning. The ETH Zurich has offered programmes such as continuing education courses and post-graduate programmes (NDS, now MAS) since 1965. The NSL (Network City and Landscape) is responsible for these courses and programmes.
    Close
  • Publications
    • NSL Newsletter – The NSL brings the experts at ETH Zurich together and also maintains a dialogue with other groups that deal with or are interested in issues relating to cities and landscapes.
    • Cover der Publikation: Erkenntnisse zum aktuellen WohnungsnotstandPublications of NSL Chairs – A complete list of publications can be reached via the following link, which also includes advanced search capabilities:
      • ETH Zürich Research Collection
    • DISP_58/3_CoverdisP – The Planning Review – The interdisciplinary scientific journal covers the topics of spatial development, urban planning, landscape and environmental planning, landscape architecture, traffic planning, and regional and environmental economics, as well as special issues on specific themes.
      • Publishing in disP – The Planning Review
      • Publisher
      • Book Review Guidelines
      • Editorial Staff
      • Latest Issue
      • facebook
    Close
  • Current
  • Contact
      • en
        • de
        • fr
        • it
      • Search

    • Close

Tensions in Participatory Work in Countries of the Global South

Participatory mapping in one of the case study sites (Madagascar). Julie Zähringer, 2016
Participatory mapping in one of the case study sites (Madagascar). Julie Zähringer, 2016

By working in a participatory manner, we aim at increasing trust, credibility, and acceptance of research results, plans, and concrete measures, but also at the self-determination of concerned actors in strategy development processes. This holds true for such processes in both foreign and domestic contexts. In foreign contexts though, the researcher might be challenged because of different codes of interaction and social backgrounds; therefore, intercultural competence is needed for collaboration. Even with the best intentions, tensions might still arise while working in foreign contexts, and thus projects require constant reflection.

The project Managing Telecoupled Landscapes aims to test, for example, if telecoupled flows of information, goods, or money and the establishment of connectivity among key actors might trigger sustainable transformations in our case study areas located in northern Laos, northeastern Madagascar, and southern Myanmar.

Work package (WP) 1 focuses on participatory mapping of past and current land-use, the assessment of ecosystem services and well-being related to land use, and social network analyses. WP2 uses this detailed land-use data for a participatory modeling exercise to provide land-use scenarios depicting possible future pathways. This constitutes – amongst other things – the foundation for WP3 that aims to facilitate and monitor learning processes within the frame of the project. In all these tasks, we want to justify using local actors’ time and explain how such data could be of use to our local partners.

However, being part of a research consortium working in these case study areas comes with great challenges: By applying a Eurocentric perspective in our research, we potentially miss local approaches to finding answers. As researchers, we are (at least partly) evaluated by the output of published scientific articles that do not target the researched community. We are also from a foreign (exogenous) context, able to afford a visit that leads to expectations from local actors that we will be able to, e.g., finance infrastructure as well.

However, our change theory is based on the hypothesis that through interactions with researchers and other stakeholders, endogenous key stakeholders can potentially change their beliefs and values in order to negotiate future development pathways. This approach is somewhat at odds with the usual recommendations expected of external (so-called) experts. However, the first step in fostering change is for researchers and collaborating partners in the case study areas to be aware of and reflect on these tensions. By taking into account the perspectives of both local actors and researchers, there could be real and productive engagement that helps the cause of the local partners. Through this process, researchers and local actors can work together at eye level – each with its given means – to ensure a sustainable transformation.

The project Managing Telecoupled Landscapes was funded by the Swiss Programme for Research on Global Issues for Development (r4d programme), started in 2015, was evaluated in 2017, and will last until 2020.

Authors: Enrico Celio, senior scientist at IRL-PLUS; Prof. Dr. Adrienne Grêt-Regamey, professor at IRL-PLUS; Peter Messerli, Professor at CDE; Flurina Schneider, PD at CDE; Manuel Fischer, Group leader at Eawag and PD at Uni Bern (IPW); Julie Zähringer, Senior scientist at CDE.

 

Share this...
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Linkedin
  • Email
This article has been published in the following newsletter edition:

37 | März 2018: Arbeiten im internationalen Umfeld / International Context Work

  • Tensions in Participatory Work in Countries of the Global South
  • Educate Global, Teach Local
  • Empower Integrated Research. Preferential City Making
  • Schweizer Planungsmethoden exportieren? Ein geglücktes Gedankenexperiment
  • Territories of Extended Urbanisation
Kurzmeldungen
  • Future of Urban Transportation: Flying Cars
  • New Project «Assessing Singapore’s Natural Capital» for More Informed and Sustainable Urban Land Planning Decisions
Publikationen
  • Geschichte und Perspektiven der schweizerischen Raumplanung. Raumplanung als öffentliche Aufgabe und wissenschaftliche Herausforderung
  • Sampling Kyoto Gardens. Pamphlet 21
  • Innovationen im intermodalen Verkehr
  • Increasing the credibility of expert-based models with preference surveys – Mapping recreation in the riverine zone
Aktuell
  • Schmelzende Landschaften
  • On Planning – A Thought Experiment
  • Menschen und ihr Zuhause: Demografische Veränderungen, technologische Innovationen & neue Märkte
  • Roberto Burle Marx, Landscape and Chromatic Relationships
  • Inclusive Marseille: MAS Urban Design
  • Exkursion: Limmattalbahn Schlieren
  • Spatial and Infrastructure Development
  • Den Lebensraum gestalten
  • Unpacking the City, Rolling out Urbanity. Concluding Symposium Kees Christiaanse
  • Urban­Think Tank: Inside & Out
  • Master of Advanced Studies ETH Urban Design 2018/2019
  • Management des öffentlichen Verkehrs für Grossveranstaltungen

Chairs

Prof. Dr. Bryan T. Adey
Prof. Dr. Kay W. Axhausen
Prof. Dr. Tom Avermaete
Prof. Maria Conen
Prof. Dr. Francesco Corman
Dr. Jennifer Duyne Barenstein
Prof. Teresa Galí-Izard
Prof. Dr. Adrienne Grêt-Regamey
Prof. Dr. Guillaume Habert
Prof. Dr. David Kaufmann
Prof. Hubert Klumpner
Dr. Anastasios Kouvelas
Prof. Freek Persyn
Prof. Dr. Christian Schmid
Prof. Milica Topalovic
EiR PD Dr. Joris Van Wezemael
Prof. em Dr. h. c. Günther Vogt
ETH Wohnforum – ETH CASE

Contact

Address
ETH Zürich
NSL – Netzwerk Stadt und Landschaft
Stefano-Franscini-Platz 5
HIL H 44.2
8093 Zürich

NSL Director
Director: Prof. Hubert Klumpner
Deputy Director: Prof. Dr. David Kaufmann

NSL Coordination
Claudia Gebert
Telephone: +41 (0)44 633 36 33

Register for the NSL Newsletter

disP Publication Office

Editor-in-Chief
Dr. sc. techn. Martina Koll-Schretzenmayr, Spatial planner ETH/NDS,
Telephone +41 (0)44 633 29 47

Editorial Assistant
Telephone +41 (0)44 633 29 69

Mailing address
ETH Zürich
Redaktion disP
NSL – Netzwerk Stadt und Landschaft
Stefano-Franscini-Platz 5
HIL H 33.2
8093 Zürich
Fax +41 (0)44 633 12 15
E-Mail

 

NSL Archive (gta)

Research and Bequest Archive for
Swiss Landscape Architecture and Spatial Planning

Consultation Requests

Mailing address
ETH Zürich
NSL Archive (gta)
Stefano-Franscini-Platz 5
HIL C 65.2
CH-8093 Zurich